Pricing model
What rate should each risk band pay?
Set a rate for each risk band of a consumer lender, and how strongly take-up reacts. Margin, loans and loss move against today’s flat 12%, and the demo shows where your rates fall behind it.
Set the rates
The rates stay as set. Today’s margin stays put, because nothing changes at today’s rate.
Margin against today
+€76,400
€202,900 against €126,500, first year, on a month's loans
Loans against today
−212
818 against 1,030 loans a month
Loss against today
−€40,900
€167,350 against €208,250, first year, on a month's loans
Ahead of today until take-up reacts about 2.8 times as strongly as assumed, then behind it. At this response, no band earns less than it does today.
Margin by band, today against the rates set
The same data as a table
| Band | Rate | Take-up | Loans | Yearly loss | Margin today | Margin at this rate | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 11% | 50% | 300 | 0.96% | €66,000 | €68,100 | +€2,100 |
| B | 14% | 38% | 266 | 2.7% | €70,000 | €77,140 | +€7,140 |
| C | 19% | 32% | 160 | 7.04% | €15,000 | €51,680 | +€36,680 |
| D | 20% | 46% | 92 | 13.2% | −€24,500 | €5,980 | +€30,480 |
| All | 818 | €126,500 | €202,900 | +€76,400 |
Where the rates set fall behind today, as take-up reacts more strongly
That chart as a table
| Response | Loans | Margin | Against today |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.5× | 924 | €232,440 | +€105,940 |
| 1.0× | 818 | €202,900 | +€76,400 |
| 1.5× | 712 | €173,360 | +€46,860 |
| 2.0× | 606 | €143,820 | +€17,320 |
| 2.5× | 550 | €130,430 | +€3,930 |
| 3.0× | 518 | €123,760 | −€2,740 |
| 3.5× | 506 | €118,390 | −€8,110 |
| 4.0× | 494 | €113,020 | −€13,480 |
What to try
The demo opens on the rate with the most margin for each band: €202,900 against today’s €126,500. Press Best single rate to see how little of that a higher average rate earns alone: €141,088 at 13.5%.
Then move the last slider. Those band rates assume a response to the rate that nobody has measured yet, and they fall behind today at about 2.8 times that response. Take-up is the number that decides it, which is why the real work measures it first.
Pull band D down to today’s 12%: it writes more loans and loses money on each, because its cost and loss come to more than the rate. Raise band A: its margin falls, because it is the band most sensitive to the rate.
Where the defaults come from
The lender: 2,000 approved applicants a month in four bands, a balance of €5,000 over the year, funding and servicing at 5.5% of it, rates from 8% to its own cap of 20%. The full example, with what each band brings, is on risk-based pricing.
Not covered
The bands and the loss in each are inputs: on real work they are your risk team’s. The demo does not score applicants, set who is approved or model credit risk. It holds the balance level for the year, treats take-up as a straight line in the rate and leaves competitors out. A response above 4 times is out of range: band A fills up while the others empty, and the line stops meaning anything.
Related: one loan priced three times, in When is charging two customers different prices defensible?; the price-test calculator, for sizing a price test; and pricing analysis, on price tests and personalised offers.
Start here
Setting rates by risk band?
Up to thirty minutes on the question and your data, then a fixed proposal.